Manual vs. Power: Choosing the Right Mobility Device

The difference between a manual and powered mobility device lies in how they are operated and the level of effort required: 

• Manual Mobility Devices: These include wheelchairs; which require the user to propel themselves using their upper body strength or with assistance from another person or rollators; which are walkers with wheels that rely on a person being able to walk, while providing stability for the person to stay upright. 
  
  
  

• Powered Mobility Devices: Motorized devices, like electric power chairs or scooters, are operated using a joystick or other controls. They are ideal for users with limited strength or endurance, providing greater independence over longer distances. 
  
  
  

Choosing between a manual or powered mobility device depends on numerous factors that impact the user's needs and well-being: 

Strength and Range of Motion 

• Manual devices require some amount of strength and stamina. Powered devices are better for users with limited strength or endurance. 

• Sufficient shoulder and arm mobility are crucial for manual wheelchair use, just as a certain level of hip and knee mobility is necessary for using a rollator. Individuals with limited movement may find a powered option more beneficial. 
  
  

Lifestyle 

• Manual devices like rollators work better for individuals who want to maintain their physical fitness. They are also more suitable for traveling a short distance or within a smaller area. 

• Powered devices are ideal for busy days, family outings, and travel when you need to cover more ground or stick to a tight schedule. 

Environment  

• Powered devices are better suited for hilly areas and challenging terrain, while manual devices are easier to maneuver indoors or in tight spaces. 

Cost 

• Powered devices typically have higher upfront costs and may require more maintenance and replacements for items such as batteries or electrical. 
  
• There are many options to choose from that can meet different budget needs for manual or powered mobility depending on features

Independence and Control 

• Some users prefer the control of a manual device; others may need a powered device to maintain their independence. 

Choosing the right mobility device is a personal decision that should be carefully considered, ideally in consultation with healthcare professionals. For more information, call 1-888-404-1724 to speak with a lifestyle specialist.